
Smoking Ban Grades
WGEM - Pro-smoking Ban coverage
Grade:
DKHQA - Pro-smoking Ban coverage
Grade:
DQHW - Pro-smokin Ban Article
Grade:
C-
Glenn Bemis – Explained the chambers stance on the issue. Let the business owners decide which direction the business will take it. 50 businesses in Adams Co. that are smoke free.
Grade: A
Dr. Kathryn Arrambide, MD– Most of the information well known and can easily be found on the web. Stats. Stats. More Stats. Just guess coming from a Dr. makes it sound better. Read prepared stats from sheets. You can find equal contradicting information on web also. Did differ with Smoke free Coalition on taverns !! Hospitals and children locations need banned.
Grade: C+
Iris Nelson – Could only hear about 1 out of 25 words she said. Quincy making choices for Quincy?? She presented council with what to appeared as a life-sized Hallmark card full of signatures with about a total of 30 names in 2” font.
Grade: Incomplete
Mary Kallner – Touching stories about family members who have died from smoking. Seems like she’s on a personal vengeance rather than seeing the big picture of economic damage it will do. Says “it’s for the children”. (no children in bars) Said would like to see restaurants ban smoking, but does not go out for drinks so that would not bother her. Restruants, children's places, but no good reason for taverns. Would like to see smoking banned altogether, but will take “anything they can get”
Grade: D
Interruption: City Councils microphone support breaks.
Grade: F
Kathy Drea – Hired Gun brought in from Springfield. Read from script. No one has lost their job due to the smoking ban? Bar closing for other reason than smoking ban? Junk science? NO economic impact ?? Bars actually gain business? Read this. Only 5 communities outside of Chicago. Threat of suing the city? The taven owner? WTF? Let me just shorten this: aside from her name and address, I don’t think any thing she said can be backed up with an ounce of fact. If so, please post it. She was not a big hit with the crowd.
Grade: F
Steve Riedl- No Show. Jim Perry presented council a stack of petitions opposing the smoking ban.
Grade: Incomplete
Don Heck – Shot from the hip. Only person who stood up for the bar business. He knows what a smoking ban will do to the bar and tavern owners from their side of the business. Most alderman were sitting up in their chairs and listening when he spoke. He also covered both sides of the issue.
Grade: A+